Saturday, 24 April 2021

Scenario and AAR El Aroussa -The Race to the Spot, 26 February 1943 Tunisia.

 

Battle for "The Spot", El Aroussa, Tunisia 26th February 1943

The History



Three days after the end of the battles at Kasserine the  Panzer Army Afrika opened Unternehmen OCHSENKOPF against the British First Army intended to drive back the allies and lift the threat to Tunis. On 26 February, as part of as part of Unternehmen OCHSENKOPF, Panzers Panzer Regiment 7 and Jaegers of 2 Jaeger Battalion Herman Goring (Kampfgruppe Kleeberg) broke through the Allied Lines in the Mahmoud Gap south west of Goubellat getting between 38 brigade and 11 brigade  and linked up with Hauptmann Schirmer's III./Fallschirmj√§ger Regiment 5.  The pushed southward toward El Arousa having cut the Medjez road the Kampfegruppe Kleeberg attempted to seize El Aroussa and cut the supply route to 38 Irish Brigade and 1 Parachute Regiment defending Bou Arada. 10 Panzers and a part of 2 Jager regiment where approaching the town from the north and threatened to overrun Y division HQ a situation the Brigadier "Nelson" Russell commanding the Divison described the situation as "unpleasant". The ordered his reserve  squadron from 51 RTR (Probably C company) back from Bou Arada to intercept and a squadron from 56 Derbyshire Yeomanry to delay the Germans and a race was on. The Brigadier described the view from the divisional HQ: 
"We estimated it would take our 9 Churchills about two hours to reach the right place to block the Bosche. So the squadron of Derbyshire Yeomanry set out to delay the Bosch Panzers for two hours on a six mile stretch of road through the hills. It was going to be quite a race, and I found, through no fault of my own, the Divisional Headquarters was a grandstand quite close to the finishing post.

The Derbyshire Yeomanry was splendid. They laid mines, put down smoke, shot their two pounders when they could and imposed all possible delay on the Panzer, and all the time the Churchills lumber on towards “The Spot”, a carefully chosen place where he should have the Bosche on toast. It was also the last possible tank position and it wouldn’t do to be too late.

I doubt if I will ever forget the closing stage of his race – it quite beat Battleships National, when I’d backed 1st and 2nd. Ten Panzers and Nine Churchills converging from right angles, quite unseen to each other, but the Panzers didn’t know about the Churchills, and the Churchills knew all about the Panzers."


Sources are from "Bloody Road to Tunis" by David Rolf, The  the war diaries of  the 51 The Royal Tank Regiment; and the 25th Tank Brigade, and Brigadier Russell's account from The Irish Brigade website.  https://www.irishbrigade.co.uk/brigadier-narratives/irish-brigade-in-tunisia-by-brigadier-nelson-russell/the-bou-arada-period-2/



Terrain


The area on  a modern map. The town of El Aroussa lies off the map south and "Steamroller Farm off the map to the north. 

Flat and open grass land and rolling fields to the South and West rise to a low ridge stretching east to west. The ridge has fields and olive grove and rises to rough forested hills to the east - the Djebel Rhijane. The ridge falls to a narrow stream at its foot over which the road passes on a narrow bridge.  The ground to the north is rough and broken. The road runs North to South and is a unmetalled but counts as road for vehicle movement. The area south of the ridge is flat open and gently rising farmland widely spaced trees and a few hedges. The fields are without crops at this time of year. 

Forces 

Historical-ish Forces - for Company Sized Battlegroup Game 

British Forces from Y Division  

970pts   BR 60 +1d6   Officers 6 Scout 5

Delaying Force from 56 Reconnaissance squadron 1 Derbyshire Yeomanry 

Armoured Car command in Daimler Dingo (Scout Artillery spotter)
2 Daimler Mk.I  Armoured Car  (Scout Mortar spotter)
1 Carrier Section of  
    3 men in Bren carrier (Officer, Mortar spotter)
    3 men with Bren
    3 men with 2" mortar
2 Infantry foot patrol each with 8 men with Bren (scout) 
1 40mm Bofors AA gun medium with truck tow
1 Battery of 2 3" mortars off table 
 


Main Force from 51 Royal Tank Regiment 
True grit  +1d6BR

Forward HQ (Senior Officer, Artillery spotter) in M5 halftrack

Forward Signals Unit - Medium Wireless truck

Forward Observer  (Artillery spotter) in Bren carrier 

1 Infantry Platoons from Faughs consists of: 
Platoon HQ of 5 men in light truck (Officer mortar spotter)
3 Rifle sections 8 men with Bren in medium truck 
1 light mortar team 2 men with 2" mortar
with 3" mortar  and Vickers MG 
2lb AT gun and light truck tow 

2 Churchill tank troops each with 4  Mk.III/IV  Churchill tanks
1  Mk. I Churchill tanks
2 1st priority artillery requests 
  

Supply column 2 Medium Truck 


German Forces from Kampfgruppe Kleeberg 

976pts  BR 71  Officers 5  Scouts 4 

Aufklarungs force from 2 Jager battalion Herman Goering Division

2 Armoured infantry patrols in Sdkfz 250/1 (Scout Mortar spotter)
1 Recce command in Sdkfz 222 (Officer Scout Artillery spotter) 
1 Armoured car Sdkfz222 (Scout Mortar spotter)
1 Assault Pioneer squad with flamethrower and 2 demolition charges in captured M3 halftrack
1 Light Bridging Unit in Sdkfz 251/7 (Bridging)
Heavy car with 20mm AA gun 

Main force from Kampfegruppe Kleeberg 

Forward HQ  Sdkfz250/3  (Senior Officer Artillery spotter) 
Luftwaffe Air Liaison Officer with  Radio Van
Forward Signals Unit - Medium Radio Truck

1 Platoon from II Co. 2 Jaeger Battalion Herman Goring
consisting of;
 
1 Jager platoon HQ 6 men in Heavy Car (Officer, Mortar spotter)
3 Jager squads  5 men in medium truck with MG42  in  medium trucks 
3 MG squads 3 men with MG42 
HMG team 3 men with hMG42  in Medium truck
Medium mortar team 3 men and loader team with 80mm mortar in Heavy Car
1 PaK38 AT guns with Sdkfz6 tow
1 additional Jaeger squad 5 men with MG42 and AT grenades in a medium truck 
1 additional Jager MG team 3 men with MG42
     
1 Panzer III platoon of 5 PzIIIG

1 Panzer platoon of 4 PzIV F2 

Off table 
2 80mm mortar
1 first priority artillery requests 
1 counter battery fire mission

Supply column 2 medium trucks

Scenario

Victory

The first battlegroup to exceed it's total battle rating must withdraw and loses the battle. If a player hold all four of the objectives then he may claim an all objective held victory regardless of battle  rating.  

Deployment 

German 
Objectives are placed on "The Spot" ridge, the road bridge over the stream  and the NE ridgeline (see map). The German  player has one objective which may be deployed anywhere outside of the main column and Aufklarung force deployment zone and not within 10 inches of another objective or the board edge. 


The German  Aufklarung force (2 Jager battalion Herman Goering  Division) deploy in the Aufklarung deployment area
The German Main column  (Panzer Regiment 7) deploy in the German main deployment area
The British Delaying force (Derbyshire Yeomanry) may deploy anywhere on the table outside the German deployment zone. 
The British Flanking force  (51RTR) deploys to the British deployment zone 

German Aufklarungs force  deploys from turn 1  may deploy anywhere within 10 inches of the German table edge.
The British Delaying force deploys from turn 1.
The delaying action by the Derbyshire Yeomanry last 3+1d3 turns.  
German Main column arrive 1d6 units per turn after the delaying action is over from the Main Force deployment zone.
British Flanking force arrives after the delaying action from the British deployment zone (20" from SW table corner) at a rate of 1d6 units per turn.

Special rules

British barrages can only be harassing barrages until the Forward Headquarters or Forward Observer in main force is deployed.  The 56 Derbyshire Yeomanry have mined the approaches therefore any special event drawn from the Battle rating counters may be used as a Mine Strike counter. Mine strike counters apply as usual but cannot be played anywhere within 5" of Assault Pioneers. The Churchill tank mobility rule applies. The highest hills are difficult terrain for vehicles (and covered in trees and scrub giving soft cover). The stream is in a deep "nullah" and crossing it is dangerous for all vehicles (except at the bridge). 

Map








AAR - "My side of the hill"


I was to play British in this scenario. Warwick kindly agreed to take on Herman Goering's attacking Panzer's find his AAR on his blog at http://warwickkinrade.blogspot.com/. I had been looking forward to this first big game since lockdowns began  I made a couple off substitutions to the lists as written in the scenario above two Sherman tanks was substituted for two Churchills and I substituted an M5 halftrack for a white scout car the Forward HQ of 51RTR. Otherwise the models came from my own collection Infantry mostly Eureka and AB miniatures Churchills and Bren Carriers from PSC and  Sherman's from Italeri

My plan was to gain the high ground of the ridge and from there engage and destroy the German forces. To achieve this I intended to use the Derbyshire Yeomanry to try and hold the line of “the Nullah” at the foot of the ridge and to delay and harass the advancing German forces as long as possible. Then I would use the motorised  Infantry  to re-enforce them as soon as the main force arrives and then to use the infantry to cover the advance of the slower Churchill tanks whose job would be to engage and destroy the German Panzers. Hopefully the Yeomanry would hold the objectives on the ridge and try and grab the bridge as well, if possible.

Figure 1 The Yeomanry deployment below the ridgeline 

 

The Infantry foot patrols deployed in cover close to the road in the olive grove and on the objective at the east of the ridge (we marked this with a tree- but it represented the best observation spot on the east of the ridge.) The Armoured cars deployed in the dead ground on the rear slope of the ridge as did the carrier section. They could move quickly to the front side of the ridge once the German first turn was over.

Figure 2 Carrier Section andvances to the Olive grove  on the front of the ridge. These did not block LoS for this game. But did provide some cover for units inside them. 

The German advance on the east side (containing the Sdkfz251/7 bridging) concerned me as I worried that the Germans might cross the Nullah and outflank the defence from that direction. So the command armoured car would advance and position itself to use the mortar battery to delay and harass this attack. Meanwhile the Daimler Armoured cars and carrier section infantry would  try an capture the bridge. The infantry foot patrols both advanced to try to get to the cover of the Nullah.

The attempt to capture the bridge by coup de main  is confounded as the tough veteran Jager pioneers who dismount from there captured M3 halftrack and take up position in the hard cover of the Nullah beside the bridge. 

Dislodging tough veteran troops like this from hard cover. I was also wary of the flamethrower that I know such troops carry any vehicle on the bridge contesting the objective would likely be an easy target for the flame thrower! The Yeomanry would need to keep there distance.

Figure 4 The Jager Pioneers take cover in the Nullah beside the Bridge objective
Fig 5 The Derbyshire Yeomanry seized the ground needed for my main force and hung on 

My concern was rapidly confirmed as fire from the Jager and mortar fire resulted in the surrender and rout of one of the foot patrols. The Daimler armoured car would now have to hold the road and I abandoned effort to attack the bridge. And decided to hold on. The German mortar began to play on the Yeomanry.

Figure 6 The Headquarters Armoured Car of the Derbyshire Yeomanry advances up the ridge 

My harassing did not prevent the MG42 fire pinning the infantry section. The Daimler Dingo armoured car HQ calling in the off table mortar fire began a long duel as the German recce infantry attempting to pin the car with long range fire from the halftracks machine guns.

Figure 7 Captured M3 Halftrack covering the bridge objective 

 The German Aufklarung's had gotten into an excellent position repeated pinning and wounding the armoured cars and infantry. I kept the Derbyshire Yeomanry in the fight taking a counter every turn when time came to roll I was alarmed to see the reconnaissance men would need to last another 3 turns. The armoured cars are nearly out of ammunition for their 2 pounder guns  I drew several special counters but the German armoured cars and halftracks were too busy laying a withering fire on my positions and not moving so I was unable to play them as Mines Strikes. But they did keep the Battle Rating lower then the Germans might think.

 

With plenty of orders and not much ammo I moved the Bofers gun up the road to threaten the German armour car beyond the bridge. It worked The Derbyshire Yeomanry are reduced to a ding and 1 Daimler and the two men with a Bren guns from the carrier section and a constantly pinned foot patrol reduced to 7 men where all that remained .

Figure 8 The 40mm Bofers gun deployed to cover the road

At last the main force began to arrive. Initials only 2 elements so I changed plan and decide to commit the Sherman's first  – my fastest moving troops in the Main force and rushed them up to the ridge I was lucky that the German main force was also arriving fitfully with just a handful of Panzers came down the road. The Sherman's engaged these The Yeomanry had hung on at a cost in BR but the Main force now need to move quickly to occupy the ridge.

Figure 9 The first Sherman III of the main force arrives. These tanks would prove more than a match for the Panzer III. 
Figure 10 Sherman's advance as the 40mm is withdrawn 

The critical factor for the rest of the game would be the arrival of each side main force. Could I get the slow but powerful Churchills onto the ridge before the German panzers could make there weight of fire tell.  With the main force also came access to the big guns on the two first priority fire request. My eye still on the bridging unit to the east (one armoured recce patrol had made it to the Nullah and brought my infantry under fire with their MG) so still concerned about being outflanked. I committed the first of my request and called on the Y Division guns. The a lucky roll saw the 4.5” howitzers are free an accurate spotting from the Yeomanry HQ in their Dingo unleashed a devastating barrage that would destroy the Bridging unit and another half track and pin the infantry in there position.

The Dingo mounted spotter decisively win there duel with the Eastern Bridge Force 
Figure 11 Quite a Stonk 

 


The eastern thrust thrust send to be neutralised and so the motorised infantry tried again for the bridge and Nullah. However the arrival and quick deployment of the tough veteran Jagers meant that the “‘Faughs” lost the race to the bridge and a viscous firefight on the slopes of the hill began. The Bridge remained just out of reach without leaving the platoon dangerously vulnerable to a counter attack or concentrated fire. Battlegroup is merciless to infantry caught without cover I dared not risk coming up short. 

Figure 13 The Faughs deploy into the scrub above the bridge 

 

Figure 14 The Platoon HQ deploy from their Morris MWB supported by the  2 pounder AT gun (this would be knocked out by a stalking MG42 team from the armoured recce patrol in the orchard)

The Churchill squadrons where arriving in force as the British main force arrived more swiftly than the German reinforcement (lucky rolls for me here). I sent the Mk I with its 3” howitzer as close support for the infantry – making good use of the Churchills mobility in hill climbs to reach them.


Figure 15 MkIII Churchill tanks of 51 RTR advance past the CMP 15cwt lorrys of the motor infantry platoon 


Figure 16 Mark III Churchills and CMP 15cwt lorries deploying infantry onto the hill beyond.


The rest pushed on to engage the German panzers. Slow reinforcements meant that the Germans where unable to build up a weight of fire and it was clear that the Panzer III are no match for the Churchill's 6 pounder main gun. The ridge now seemed secure so sending an early arrival.

Figure 17 The Main Force Infantry and AT gun (pinned) in front the mixed Mark III and Mark IV Churchills line up exchanging fire with the Panzers beyong the ridge and preparing to advance. 
Figure 17 The German position as there main force schlerotically arrives. The Jagers trucks on the left. The Pak 38 deploys to cover the bridge. Meanwhile the Panzer III lead the way and the Panzer IV specials at the back

 The Tank “Adventurer” down the road to challenge control of the bridge the rest of the Churchills began to advance by bounds. I intended to use their excellent frontal armour and mobility to roll down the ridge and force the German Panzers to stop me. 

Figure 18 Churchill Mk III "Adventurer" reaches the bridge. The far end is blocked by a Panzer III 

A Churchill hit a mine but it’s excellent rear armour meant is shrugged off the strike. The Panzer IV specials long 75mm had quite a dose of bad luck technically they have a good chance of penetrating the frontal armour but could not manage it once despite several good hits. The Panzer IV own armour proved horribly vulnerable to the Churchills main gun as the advance started to look unstoppable.

The Churchills exchange fire with Panzer III firing HE to try and suppress the heavier tanks 


Figure 19 The general position around the bridge around turn 10. As a Panzer III targets the side armour of a Churchill. Sherman tanks are still forward at this point engaging the  Panzer III.
Figure 20 A Panzer III duels the Churchill Mk III on the bridge, The Jagers of Rgt 2 have taken the Nullah beside the bridge others swarm up the rocky hillside towards the British defenders 
Figure 22 Adventurers contests the bridge - not sure that it looks like it could take a 40 ton weight! The Panzer III outflank in the background but at a terrible cost. 
Figure 22 Churchill three pushes past a KO'ed Daimler Armoured Car.
Figure 23 The Churchill Mk1 opperates as support to the infantry on the rough hillside making good use of the 3" howitzer.

The Forward HQ came forward to the ridge crest to spot for the artillery. The Dingo sadly falling victim to another Mine Strike (probably one of the Derbyshire Yeomanry's own mines!). Another good set of rolls brought the Y division 4.5” guns into play again this time the Panzers where the focus another excellently spotted stonk straddled the Panzer IV causing pins and direct hits. Even the Germans own forward HQ was caught up in the chaos. A direct hit destroyed yet another   Panzer IV. As the first of the Churchill tanks  crossed the Nullah at its midway point the German  forces realised that they had lost the race and began to with draw.

Figure 24 The divisonal artillery played a crucial role in breaking up the Panzers attack as well as knocking out several


Figure 25 The general position as the German push finally runs out of steam. The guns of Y division hitting the Panzer IV tanks 
Figure 26 The source of that gun fire the Forward HQ on the ridge 

Historically the Herman Goering division withdrew Kampfgruppe Kleeberg to “Steamroller farm” back 6 miles up the Goubellat road. They would face the 51RTR this time supported by the Coldstream Guards the next day. That battle scenario is cover in my blog post – the battle of Steamroller Farm above !  

Final Score for the British forces. Feeling confident. Two chits for air attack neither turn up! 

  

Final Score  for German Force - remarkable numbers of 4 and 5 chits - the sudden German collapse had been a surprise. 

Tuesday, 20 April 2021

Scenario and AAR Probing "Pots and Pans" Imphal '44 - C "Commando" platoon, 9 Borders at Potsangbam, near Imphal 7 May 1944

C "Commando" platoon, 9 Borders Potsangbam, near Imphal  7 May 1944


History 

Imphal was a road junction and a vital supply dump for the Allied forces of 14th Army In India. It stands close to the Burmese border and the passes through the jungle cover Chin Hills that mark that rugged border.  General Mutaguchi commanding the Imperial Japanese Army in Burma ordered the attack with troops of the 33rd, 31st and 15th Division along with substantial support from the Indian National Army and they crossed the Chindwin River on 8th of March to cross the hills on foot. General Scoones commanding IV Corp  was aware of the attack but not its scale or the timing He therefore concentrated his forces toward Imphal. Whilst General Slim of 14th Army flew in troops including the 17th Diviison and M3 tanks of the 3 Carabiner (Prince of Wales Dragoon Guards)  

The  Battle of Bishenpur is the name given to the fighting that took place on or near the Tiddim Road south of Imphal between early April and early May and as such is one part of the much larger battle of Imphal. The Japanese  33rd Division  came up against the last British defences south of Imphal. The Tiddim Road ran almost straight across the open paddy fields of the Imphal plain. Along the length of the road lay the villages to one side or the other. Colonel Taguchi, commander of the Engineer Regiment, would take his own 4th Independent Engineer Regiment, 2/213 Battalion (less two companies), and an anti-tank detachment up the road to Bishenpur. They seized Potsangbam driving out British Indian Army  patrols on the night of   May and heavily fortifying the village. The 9th Borderers arrived with 48 brigade of 17th  "Black Cat" Davison soon after and began to probe the village. Unaware of the true strength on the Japanese or the degree to which they had dug in early patrols where repulsed. This is one such action. 


"I was given the order to advance with the platoon of 22 men along a wide track, with a monsoon ditch on either side, then jungle.

We had not got far when a mortar bomb (from our own mortars) fell behind us with disastrous results.

I regrouped with 17 men. We continued the advance with a bunker well hidden by the enemy.

I was ordered to withdraw and let a tank to go forward. This attack failed, the tank could not depress his gun low enough to hit the target."

from: 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/history/ww2peopleswar/stories/16/a2422216.shtml

and 

more details of the first battle of Bishenapur can be found at https://www.worldhistory.biz/sundries/15832-chapter-nine.html

Terrain

 The road is a muddy track and does not give any movement benefits. The Jungle scrub limits line of sight to 30" and the Thick Jungle of banana  limits the line of sight to 20". The monsoon ditches lie on either side of the road and allow infantry full movement but are impassable to vehicles and it soft cover. The paddy field beyond the jungle around the village are dried out at this time. The bunds around the field provide hard cover,  The jungle and jungle scrub is soft cover. The foxhole and bunkers and spider holes provide reinforced cover for their occupants. 
Forces 

British Indian Army 
from 17th Black Cat Division 

"C" Commando platoon, 9 Border Regiment  (understrength) -

Platoon HQ 3 men  Officer, Mortar Spotter 

I "Tiger" recon patrol 3 men (scouts)

2 sections each of 6 men (regular) 

1 LMG section  6 men with 3 Bren LMG

1 2" mortar section 2 men 

1 Sniper (scout) 

1 Anti Tank team 2 men with Boyes Anti Tank rifle

 support 2 3" mortars (off table) 

3 Carabiner (Prince of Wales Own) 

1 M3 Grant Tank


from Imperial Japanese Army 33rd Division

2 squads from 213 Regiments 

each consists of 


Deployment

The British deploy 1d6 units into the deployment zone in the corner of the table deployment zone. The Japanese player then deploys all troops and defences. The Japanese player may keep 1d6 unit as an off table reserve. The remainder of the British force arrives in there deployment zone after turn 3. 

Victory

The objectives are the bunker, There are two other objectives which may be places one by each side in the Japanese deployment zone. The Japanese cannot win an all objectives claimed victory

Map



AAR


British Force  Commando platoon and supporting M3 tank from 3rd Carabiners  

Infantry of the defenders 2 infantry squads from 213 Regiment 







Each Infantry section has a Rifle element, an LMG element and an Antitank element with pole mine

Japanese sniper in spider hole - well concealed and with overhead cover he is hard to spot and hard to hit. 

Japanese deploy there defences foxholes for the two LMG sections  each supported by a spider hole with and LMG and a grenade launcher

The Heavy Machinegun bunker covers the road supported from either side by the infantry dug in and well concealed .

The second set of foxholes cover the far side of the road 

The LMG in a spiderhole covers the flank

The Commando platoon deploy all there Bren guns as a base of fire using the bund of the paddy as hard cover.

The HQ deploy into the jungle scrubs with the Medical Orderly in support.

The British 50mm mortar deploys in the jungle scrub beyond the road. It will cover the advance right flank 

Commando platoons "Tiger" scout deploy in the monsoon ditch with a line of site to the bunker

The Bren section are supported by an understrength rifle section beside the paddy field bund. The Japanese LMG opens fire from the spider hole pinning the Brens. (indicated by the casualty marker.

The second rifle section use the Monsoon ditch to advance. The M3 has advances under mortar fire an extremely fortunate hit from a British mortar pins the bunker but the tank is unable to spot the bunker with its 75mm.

The M3 struggled to spot the bunker as it was not firing! 


Japanese infantry move through the jungle to support the advancing reserve of the two antitank teams  
Mortar fire bracket the bunker again. 

The suicide antitank teams creep closer to the tank along the edge of the jungle

Japanese  rifle section pinned in the monsoon ditch by mortar fire 

The infantry close with the Japanese defences. 

The extent of the British advance is show below, Will the tank be outflanked. The British infantry platoons are attempting to cover the tank as it seeks to KO the bunker. The British lose the Tiger scouts to fire from the foxholes  pinned by sniper fire they retreat. But advance on the left suppressing and killed the LMG in it;s spiderhole. 
The Japanese force are starting to get pinned all over the table. The Japanese are reluctant to draw another Battle Rating counter. 

 How ever the  2" mortar pins one of the Nikeki antitank team as the cross the swamp land whilst the M3 Grant uses it machine guns pin te second team. The Japanese player is finally forced on risk a battle rating counter to unpin. And breaks the Japanese Battle Rating they withdraw and the British gain a foothold in the village 
Nikeki team pinned!

The British got liucky with there BR counter pulls although no plane turns up and the Japanese didn't have any artillery but they kept the total low.  

The Japanese series of unlucky chit pulls broke them in the end! 















Scenario and AAR El Aroussa -The Race to the Spot, 26 February 1943 Tunisia.

  Battle for "The Spot", El Aroussa, Tunisia 26th February 1943 The History Three days after the end of the battles at Kasserine t...